Budget 2018: State investment returns now biggest contributor of government revenue, economy in trouble

Budget 2018 and recent budgets confirm one thing: our economy is in trouble.

In managing Singapore as a corporation, the PAP government should be able to generate revenue mostly from direct and indirect taxes.  Instead, it has been increasingly reliant on contributions from “Investment and Interest” returns under the NIR framework.

While it’s fine to supplement revenue from other sources such as returns from state investments, it is ridiculous when NIR contributions become the biggest contributor of government revenue.
1budget15PAP’s reliance on NIR contributions is akin to a company CEO requesting Ah Kong for more funds to supplement dwindling revenue.  Or face inevitable collapse.

Since 2000, PAP has been tapping on increasing NIR contributions to supplement government revenue.  Hmm … an economy that has been booming but could not generate sufficient revenue?

Just how much have NIR contributions increased?  When PM Lee took over from Lau Goh in 2004, NIR was $3 billion.  Fast forward 15 years, NIR contributions have increased by at least 500% to $15.9 billion.
1budget14

The PAP has already laid the groundwork for future NIR contributions increase because our ‘economic growth’ will not generate sufficient government revenue.

To confirm this, PAP has already planned to increase GST by 2% after GE2020.

That PAP needs to constantly supplement government revenue with other sources of income in a ‘booming’ economy can mean only one thing: our economy is in trouble.

PS
Part of NIR contributions are in fact returns which belong to CPF members, not just Ah Kong money.
1budget16PAP has cleverly concealed this from propaganda loving citizens by legislating CPF as state reserves.  All investment returns by GIC using state reserves subsequently belong to the government.

This entry was posted in Budget. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Budget 2018: State investment returns now biggest contributor of government revenue, economy in trouble

  1. Anonymous incognito4444 says:

    This figures underscore thst the govt sector is far too big and has crowded out the private sector. Again the solution is to liquidate Temask and get the private sector to build stuff.

    • Phillip Ang says:

      About 20 years ago, there was talk about reduction of GLCs. But that was, and still is, impossible because this is PAP’s vote buying machine. Without GLCs, retired paper generals may revolt if they discover their true worth in the private sector. Those from SPF will not be having cushy jobs in Certis Cisco or Aetos, both TLCs. What about retired elite admin service officers and ministers’ relatives?
      With PAP in power, it looks like the opposite will happen. 😦

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s