PAP government must stop fabricating and perpetuating half-truths

Many Singaporeans are disgusted by ministers who engage in half-truths, such as Khaw Boon Wan and (former) Mah Bow Tan.

Both have insisted that HDB has been incurring humongous losses year after year, with no end in sight, despite knowing for a fact that this is a half-truth. This is because HDB pays market rate for land cost to Singapore Land Authority (SLA), ie if HDB has been making losses, then PAP should disclose SLA’s humongous profits.

It’s immoral to include land cost at market rate in selling HDB flats because HDB lessees could never own the land. This is common sense.

Although Leong Sze Hian has already written on the issue of HDB land cost component, it’s still worth the effort to continue educating Singaporeans, including propaganda lovers, on this immoral policy. Another example:

In 2011, HDB awarded the 1009-unit Waterway Cascadia project valued at $161.2 million to WTP (image below). In 2016, flat buyers received their keys to 242 3-room, 500 4-room and 267 5-room premium flats.


The minimum prices of these flats were $204,000, $$310,000 and $390,000 for 3-,4- and 5-room flats respectively, excluding grants. A few things to note:

– Grants are only a fraction of a HDB flat land cost component.
– There are too many different types of CPF grants which look good on PAPer but in reality, most buyers are ineligible for the maximum grants.
– Higher floor = Higher flat price.

For ease of calculation, let’s use HDB’s minimum selling price to calculate its revenue (table below).

Has HDB been making billion-dollar losses?

Flat type Minimum price No. of units Sub total
3-Room $204,000 242 $49,368,000
4-Room $310,000 500 $155,000,000
5-Room $390,000 267 $104,130,000
Construction costs: $161,200,000 Total revenue $308,498,000
Estimated profit $147,298,000

When ministers do not paint the full picture, ie leaving out the land cost component earned by SLA, they are clearly talking cock and trying to hoodwink citizens.

Singaporeans must be wary of such ministers because if we continue to live in la la land, HDB flats will become even more unaffordable for future generations.

The PAP should manage the country properly by generating real economic growth to earn government revenue. It should cease earning revenue via selling public housing at exorbitant prices, high COE prices, confiscating CPF members’ returns, etc.

Quote: “The half-truth is the most dangerous form of lie, because it can be defended in part by incontestable logic”. Ministers should cease fabricating and perpetuating half truths because they risk being called L _ _ R S.

This entry was posted in POLITICS. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to PAP government must stop fabricating and perpetuating half-truths

  1. Silas says:

    The contractor is Progressive Builders Pte Ltd. Cost estimation is done by WTP. Other than that, you are right that Singapore government is earning huge profits building HDB flats by making land cost high. I can even bet that HDB bought land above market rate since HDB flats nowadays are stacked to 40 storeys high. If you get the land area of the development, and calculate the cost per unit land area with nearby landed properties owned by the elites, you may even discover that HDB owners are subsidizing these rich people.

  2. Silas says:

    I wonder why these companies do not disclose their organization chart on their website. What do these companies have to hide? Who are the directors and CEO? Are they cronies of some ah kow ah niao ministers? Why do HDB not mandate public disclosure of contract sums of projects on their website? Why do they deal with seemingly shady companies? Are there any kickbacks??

    • Phillip Ang says:

      It appears a lot of material info has been hidden. Any company which earns millions in tax dollar revenue should disclose all material information but it is the norm to withhold such information. Another obvious question which WP has not raised.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s