20140624 CPF – Lim Swee Say at his nonsensical best!

ST headline “CPF money 100% safe: Swee Say” caught my eye. I knew anything related to Lim Swee Say, minister with zero portfolio with a fetish for DTF toothpicks, would be interesting. The more our government emphasises the ‘safety’ of CPF monies in the absence of transparency, the more CPF members should worry.

Source: Straits Times

Second paragraph: “While many investments had been lost during the global financial crisis, he pointed out, CPF had still continued to earn interest then”.

What does “many investments” mean in dollar value? $10 billion? $50 billion? That “CPF had still continued to earn interest then” is obviously redundant. Swee Say loves to highlight the obvious but does not provide any supporting data. Talk is cheap. It’s like telling Singaporeans ‘the sun will rise tomorrow”. No, not just “tomorrow” but “tomorrow morning”.

Third paragraph: “(The) money with CPF.. was not only safe, but continued to earn risk-free interest”. Who is Swee Say trying to kid? First he says “many investments had been lost” (billions) and a few seconds later claims CPF money “was not only safe, but..”.

Swee Say has certainly mastered the art of speaking half-truths: “You have the money, the account, and you receive the statement of accounts on a regular basis, so you know exactly how much money you have. CPF money is something that “nobody can take away”.

Oh really? “Nobody can take away” our money? Swee Say should be upfront and tell the student participants the PAP government has been helping themselves to OUR CPF monies through legislation, locked them away in a ‘55 till 65 cannot touch account’ and then subject members to a ‘monthly installment until you mati’ scheme.

Recall Minister Khaw had recently said about having a degree: “You own a degree, but so what? That you can’t eat it. If that cannot give you a good life, a good job, it is meaningless”. Using Khaw’s logic, the students should have told Swee Say: “You have a CPF account, receive statement of accounts on a regular basis and know how much money you have, so what? If the money ‘can see no touch’ for 10 years and cannot give us a good life, it is meaningless.”

Swee Say should be upfront and inform the student participants that the dominant party in parliament is able to shift the CPF goalposts any time, any where. Withdrawal age has already been shifted 10 years, from 55 to 65; the PAP could easily, and likely, raise this to even 70 with no resistance in parliament.

Swee Say also said our “CPF is 100% safe and is protected against events like the global financial crisis”. This is clearly false as the market value of CPF investments in GIC were decimated during the crisis.

It is almost impossible to believe a confused cabinet minister could have made such comments. But then again, coming from Lim Swee Say, nothing is impossible.

This entry was posted in CPF, POLITICS. Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to 20140624 CPF – Lim Swee Say at his nonsensical best!

  1. James says:

    Couldn’t agree more. If there’s a University for morons, this guy will achieve triple first class honours!

  2. Isupportyou says:

    Philip, you are spot on. Good work. Your analyses are fantastic.

  3. Alan says:

    Jialat, he said many investments had been lost but provide no details. How come he seems to know something which we all don’t know ? How about telling us in another ‘honest conversation’ who is responsible for such losses, was it due to LHL, Ho Jinx or LKY ?

    Remember to be honest with us but don’t anyhow sue us for nothing ?

    • phillip ang says:

      “Many investments had been lost” will soon be Swee Say’s most popular quote. We all must thank Swee Say for letting the cat out of the bag. 🙂

  4. Kojak Bt says:

    Bro, you write very well. Are you ok if we repost some of your articles on TRE? Thanks!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s